Best Sandwiches in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY

Stacked High, Made Fresh, Served with Heart Every Time

Order Online

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

Turkey Club Sandwich

Turkey breast, bacon, Swiss cheese, mesclun, avocado, tomato and Russian dressing on white Pullman bread

Add Item

Emiliano Sandwich

Prosciutto, Mozzarella, house-made pesto, fresh roma tomatoes, arugula and balsamic vinaigrette on ciabatta

Add Item

El Cubano Sandwich

Slow-cooked leg of pork (pernil), smoked virginia ham, Swiss cheese, dill pickles and mustard pressed on Portuguese bread

Add Item

Creamy Tomato Soup

Add Item

Welcome to The Sandwich Shop 🥪

Serving up authentic sandwiches, bowls, and soups with fresh, locally sourced ingredients, this Brooklyn spot is where great food meets casual comfort. From the bold El Cubano to the creamy tomato soup, there's something for everyone. Enjoy quick online ordering or relax inside for a cozy dine-in experience.

A Sandwich with a Story 📖

The Emiliano Sandwich was inspired by a family recipe passed down through generations and carries the name of one of our family members. Built on layers of tradition, it features Prosciutto, Mozzarella, house-made pesto, fresh roma tomatoes, arugula, balsamic vinaigrette, and fresh-baked bread—always crafted with care. It’s more than a sandwich—it’s a bite of heritage straight from our Brooklyn kitchen.

Explore Our Menu

A Place for Everyone

Bright and casual—our space is designed to make you feel at ease the moment you walk in. With a warm, inviting atmosphere and cozy fast-casual vibes, it’s the perfect spot to relax and enjoy your meal.

Order From Our Website

Skip the line and get your favorites fast. Whether you’re at work, home, or on the go, our easy online ordering lets you grab your meal with just a few clicks. Fresh, fast, and ready when you are.

Order Now

See What’s On the Menu

Our food is stacked, saucy, and ready for its close-up. Take a peek at the meals our guests can’t stop coming back for.

We Cater and We Cater Good!

Make your event one to remember with catering that’s fresh, bold, and made for sharing. Whether it’s a work meeting, birthday, or casual get-together, our menu delivers quality you can count on. Order with ease and let the food speak for itself—no fuss, just good eats.

Bring The Flavor To Your Event

Follow us on our Socials!

Craving more than just great sandwiches? Follow us on social media for mouthwatering updates, daily specials, and behind-the-scenes bites. Join The Sandwich Shop community—fresh content served daily!

Socials

What our guests are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

I’m not one to exaggerate my food experiences. When I say this was one of the best sandwiches I’ve had in New York city, that is absolutely true. The Emiliano sandwich is what I’ll be sharing with my out of town guests — it’s that good.

Greg M.

Lovely ambience. The owners are the best. The food was delicious, high quality and savory. It was worth it.

Jessica D.

I love this little shop! They have a big selection of sandwiches that are delicious and also some unique ones if you’re looking for something creative. They are pretty quick for delivery, pickup or eating in. The turkey delight is amazing and they use really good bread for all their sandwiches! 10/10.